Skip to content
πŸŽ‚ Need a cake ASAP? Order online now!
πŸŽ‚ Need a cake ASAP? Order online now!
Red Velvet New York Style Cookies πŸͺ - Cupcake Sweeties

New York Style Cookies Mixed Boxes πŸ’•

$0.00 - $60.00
$0.00
$36.00
$36.00 - $114.00
$36.00

New York Style Cookie Mixed Boxes πŸ’•

A gift box filled with a delicious mix of our thick, chewy NYC-style cookies β€” perfect for sharing, gifting or trying a selection of flavours.

Each box includes a mixed assortment of flavours, packed with indulgent fillings, chocolate chunks and toppings.

Enjoy them straight from the pack, or warm in the microwave for around 20 seconds for an extra-soft, gooey centre.

Please allow at least 24 hours’ notice.

Please note: Flavours vary depending on availability. All our NYC cookies are now finished with toppings, and some product photos may show an earlier style without toppings.

Pick Up & Delivery

Pickup is available from our Waterloo, Lower Hutt store on your selected date.

Same-day Wellington delivery is available.

Nationwide orders are sent Monday to Wednesday to help ensure your cookies do not sit with the courier over the weekend.

Rural delivery is available at your risk. We are unable to deliver to PO Boxes.

Delivery Pricing

Same-day Wellington-area delivery – $22
β€’ Rush delivery to Lower Hutt or Wellington CBD before 11:30 am – $40
β€’ Nationwide delivery – $9

Gifting

NYC cookies are beautifully gift boxed and finished with ribbon and a gift card.

No receipt is included with gift orders.

Storage

Storage & Serving

NYC cookies arrive individually packaged in sealed bags.

Store in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight. Try warming in the microwave for approximately 20 seconds before serving!

Dietary & Allergens

Ingredients and allergens vary by flavour. Please check the individual flavour listing for full details.

Contains: Gluten (wheat), milk, egg and soy. Some flavours also contain tree nuts.

Our kitchen handles gluten, dairy, eggs, nuts, soy and other allergens, so we cannot guarantee these cookies are free from traces.

Let customers speak for us

from 1239 reviews
Cake Craft | 390 Mini Cupcake Papers | Rose Gold Foil | 72 Approx |
Sue Allan
Amazing

Took my grandies to the icing of cupcakes. Young woman taking class was amazing. Owner of shop
(?). Was there also. Just so patient and made the experience wonderful. Thank you so much.

Cake Craft | 390 Mini Cupcake Papers | Rose Gold Foil | 72 Approx |
Pam
Fantastic

Fantastic macarons!!!

Cupcake Sweeties
Custom Edible Image Printing | A4
Shelley Marshall

Called into the store and the friendly staff were amazing, very helpful and printed my image instantly.

Custom Edible Image Printing | A4
Anonymous
Always yummy

Always yummy and of high quality

Cupcake Sweeties
Denise Venter
Highly recommend!

Time flies when you're having fun! 🧁 I absolutely recommend attending a cupcake class for the fun and to learn more about decorating cupcakes. I had a fabulous time and am so proud of my end product. Time to have more fun! Already book for my next class.

Cupcake Sweeties
Beginners Cupcake Decorating Class
Maia
What a fun way to spend a day!!

We had an absolute blast! Our instructor was so lovely (and talented!) and we learnt so much! Those who I shared my cupcakes with have asked me to do another class next week hehe

Beginners Cupcake Decorating Class
Kids School Holidays Cupcake Classes!
Yvonne Graham
Fun with cupcakes

My granddaughters 7 and 11 had so much fun making their cupcakes, they loved it. Thankyou we will be back for more.

Kids School Holidays Cupcake Classes!
Karyn
The cup cakes were a client gift and they were thoroughly enjoyed

The cup cakes were a client gift and they were thoroughly enjoyed.1

Cupcake Sweeties
Dale Laurent
Mini NY cookies

The mini NY cookies are super delicious and the right size for a little treat for the drive home😍

Cupcake Sweeties
Kids School Holidays Cupcake Classes!
Steph McGhie
Such a great little class!

Such a cool idea, My 8yr old absolutely loved her beginners class, she came out beaming and so proud of her cupcakes. Such friendly and patient staff too, she has already asked to do another class!

Kids School Holidays Cupcake Classes!
Zoe Taylor
Delicious 10/10

Delicious cupcakes and cookies!!

Cupcake Sweeties
LorAnn Flavour Oils | Banana Creme | 30ml (1oz)
Cally
Brilliant - Perkynana Flavour

Very hard to get banana flavouring that really works at all in NZ, so thrilled this one works brilliantly. It has that "fake banana" flavour you get in most sweets, my ice-cream tasted like Perkynana! Used 1 tsp per litre of ice-cream, so will need to come back for more pretty soon. Also, despite it being bright yellow, I'll need to add some yellow food colouring to get it beyond the very palest of lemon. But 11/10 for doing the key job!

LorAnn Flavour Oils | Banana Creme | 30ml (1oz)
Sam
Absolutely fantastic cupcakes! Also caters for

Absolutely fantastic cupcakes! Also caters for gluten free and vegan

Cupcake Sweeties
Liz Pullman
The gluten free cup cakes that I purchased at the last minute

The gluten free cup cakes that I purchased at the last minute,for my sisters birthday were beautiful. The team was amazing, so helpful and made the experience so easy. Would recommend to anyone.

Cupcake Sweeties
Marianne Ahpene
Needed a treat

Needed a treat and found the best treat for myself and the family. Didn't really want to share but the cupcakes are far too good not to share. Best cupcakes ever.

Cupcake Sweeties
Descriptionβ–Ύ

New York Style Cookie Mixed Boxes πŸ’•

A gift box filled with a delicious mix of our thick, chewy NYC-style cookies β€” perfect for sharing, gifting or trying a selection of flavours.

Each box includes a mixed assortment of flavours, packed with indulgent fillings, chocolate chunks and toppings.

Enjoy them straight from the pack, or warm in the microwave for around 20 seconds for an extra-soft, gooey centre.

Please allow at least 24 hours’ notice.

Please note: Flavours vary depending on availability. All our NYC cookies are now finished with toppings, and some product photos may show an earlier style without toppings.